33 Outlandish Mafia Names And The Absurd Stories Behind Them (2023)

1 of 34

Al "Scarface" Capone

Al Capone got his nickname after having his face slashed open with a broken bottle at the Harvard Inn bar in Coney Island.

It was before the infamous bootlegging king of Chicago took over the Windy City that he made an indecent remark to a woman. Her brother left Capone with new scars — and a nickname he hated.

Capone died of cardiac arrest in 1947, after complications from pneumonia, a stroke, and syphilis.

PhotoQuest/Getty Images

2 of 34

Israel "Ice Pick Willie" Alderman

Israel "Ice Pick Willie" Alderman (sixth from left) worked as a ruthless mob enforcer in Minneapolis — with his penchant for jabbing his namesake into a victim’s brain through their ear canal.Similar to Al Capone, Alderman was incarcerated for tax evasion — rather than his gruesome crimes.Southern Nevada Jewish Heritage Project

3 of 34

Vincent "Mad Dog" Coll

Irish-born New Yorker Vincent "Mad Dog" Coll was a hitman for the mob in the 1920s and 1930s. Vincent was notorious for kidnapping other gangsters for ransom money and his nickname resulted from one such kidnapping attempt in 1931.

His target was bootlegger Joseph Rao, but the ensuing gunfight saw a five-year-old boy killed in the crossfire. It was New York City Mayor Jimmy Walker who dubbed him a "Mad Dog." Coll was murdered outside of a drugstore in 1932.

Wikimedia Commons

4 of 34

Philip "The Chicken Man" Testa

Philip "The Chicken Man" Testa was briefly the leader of the Philadelphia crime family. He garnered his nickname because of his involvement in the poultry business.

Testa was murdered during the Ides of March, killed by a nail bomb planted under his front porch. It sparked a mob war, and inspired Bruce Springsteen’s "Atlantic City" lyrics: "Well they blew up the Chicken Man in Philly last night/And they blew up his house too."

Wikimedia Commons

5 of 34

Tommaso "The Boss Of Two Worlds" Buscetta

Tommaso Buscetta was the first member of the Sicilian Mafia to break omertà — the group's stringent code of silence. As "The Boss of Two Worlds," the Sicilian drug smuggler become a pentito, or informant, who testified in court against mobsters and corrupt politicians.Buscetta died of cancer in April 2000 at 71 years old, and was buried under a false name in Miami, Florida.Wikimedia Commons

6 of 34

Ciro "The Artichoke King" Terranova

Ciro "The Artichoke King" Terranova was born in Corleone, Sicily — like The Godfather, himself. After moving to New York in 1893, he ventured into organized crime during a power vacuum and took over the Morello family.

His nickname came from his regular purchase of all the artichokes that came into New York, before selling them for as much as thrice the price. After two strokes, Terranova died of heart failure, or of “a broken heart” as another mafioso, Joe Valachi, would later claim, at age 49, in February 1938.

Wikimedia Commons

7 of 34

Joseph "Joe Bananas" Bonanno

Joseph "Joe Bananas" Bonanno directed one of the five original New York City crime families. He detested his nickname, because it implied he was crazy.

On the other hand, he did illegally sneak into the United States from Sicily and violated the Mafia's code of secrecy when he published a tell-all book and appeared on 60 Minutes. He died of heart failure in 2002.

Bill Bridges/The LIFE Images Collection/Getty Images

8 of 34

Anthony "Tony Jack" Giacalone

Anthony "Tony Jack" Giacalone was born in Detroit to Sicilian parents. Since there were countless other gangsters named Anthony, Giacalone's nickname was one of necessity rather than artistry.

When Jimmy Hoffa disappeared in the 1970s, Giacalone's name garnered more attention — as he was in the International Brotherhood of Teamsters that opposed Hoffa's wish to returning to their ranks. Giacalone died of heart failure in 2001.

Wikimedia Commons

9 of 34

Francis "Cadillac Frank" Salemme

Francis "Cadillac Frank" Salemme worked at a body shop and specialized in Cadillacs before he became a murderer. However, he earned the moniker by having an employee key every 30th or 40th car, just so he could charge customers for a repair.

Salemme was suspected of murdering a federal witness, a Boston nightclub owner, in 1993, decades before vital evidence could imprison him. Finally, in 2016 they found the remains. Salemme remains behind bars.

Ed Farrand/The Boston Globe/Getty Images

10 of 34

Donald "The Wizard Of Odds" Angelini

Donald "The Wizard of Odds" Angelini was a member of the Chicago Outfit, which was previously run by Al "Scarface" Capone. He was not only its primary enforcer in Las Vegas, but also operated an extremely lucrative sports betting empire in the desert city.

Angelini was sentenced to 37 months in prison in 1989 as a result of illegal gambling charges. He died in 2000.

Pinterest

11 of 34

Anthony "The Ant" Spilotro

Anthony "The Ant" Spilotro was a second-generation Italian-American whose parents ran a restaurant frequented by the Chicago mob.

He garnered his nickname after FBI Special Agent William Roemer referred to him as "that little pissant." Unfortunately for the media, they couldn't use the term — leading to the shortened moniker. The murderous gangster was found dead and half naked in an Indiana cornfield in 1986.

Getty Images

12 of 34

Anthony "Big Tuna" or "Joe Batters" Accardo

Anthony "Big Tuna" or "Joe Batters" Accardo once ruled the Chicago Outfit, and earned his "Joe Batters" nickname during Prohibition from murdering three disloyal gangsters with a baseball bat.

Capone allegedly said, "Boy, this kid's a real Joe Batters."

The other moniker was birthed by the city's press after Accardo was photographed with a large tuna he caught on a fishing trip. He died in 1992 — after which the executive director of the Chicago Crime Commission, Robert F. Fuesel, said the Capone era had finally ended.

Wikimedia Commons

13 of 34

Frank "Superfly" Lucas

Frank "Superfly" Lucas was immortalized on celluloid when Denzel Washington portrayed the 1970s drug kingpin in American Gangster. Decades earlier, Lucas built an empire by smuggling 98-percent-pure heroin from Vietnam into the U.S. and becoming Harlem royalty.

The nickname stemmed from the famous chinchilla attire he was photographed in, drawing comparisons to the 1972 blaxploitation classic about a black pimp and cocaine dealer.

Wikimedia Commons

14 of 34

Albert "Tick Tock" Tannenbaum

Albert "Tick Tock" Tannenbaum was a professional hitman for Murder, Inc. — the official enforcement arm of the Italian-American Mafia, Jewish mob, and other criminal entities operating in New York.

The World War I veteran worked at a resort upstate that was routinely frequented by Jewish mobsters from Manhattan. His nickname came from the fact that he just couldn't shut up — with his restless nervousness reminding New York mobster Jacob Shapiro of a clock.

Tannenbaum died in 1976.

Pinterest

15 of 34

Ellsworth Raymond "Bumpy" Johnson

Ellsworth Raymond "Bumpy" Johnson derived his nickname from a bump on the back of his head he had since birth. He was sent to live in Harlem with his sister, after the family fled South Carolina fearing a lynch mob.

Johnson was convicted in New York for conspiracy to sell heroin in 1951, and died of congestive heart failure in 1968.

Wikimedia Commons

16 of 34

Frank "The Prime Minister" Costello

As boss of the Genovese crime family, Frank "The Prime Minister" Costello was aptly named as such for his well-established and connected status in the underworld.

Not only was he an essential part of the Castellammarese War in the 1930s, but he also survived an assassination attempt and successfully retired before the U.S. Senate indicted him.

Costello died of a heart attack in February 1973, and was buried in Queens, New York.

Wikimedia Commons

17 of 34

Vincent "The Chin" Gigante

Vincent "The Chin" Gigante ran the Genovese crime family for nearly 25 years. The former professional boxer garnered his nickname from his resilience in the ring.

Gigante failed to murder Frank Costello, yet scared him enough to make him retire. Convicted of racketeering and murder conspiracy in 1997, Gigante died in a federal prison in 2005 and was buried in anonymity in New York. His relatives still earn $2 million per year as gainful employees of corporations on the New Jersey waterfront.

Apic/Getty Images

18 of 34

Salvatore "Little Caesar" Maranzano

Salvatore "Little Caesar" Maranzano was nicknamed for a penchant right out of a Martin Scorsese movie. The mobster was purportedly so fascinated by Ancient Rome and Julis Caesar that his less-educated peers were not only annoyed with him but also gave him the cheeky nickname in response.

Maranzano became capo dei capi, or "boss of all bosses," before Charles "Lucky" Luciano murdered him, fearing a hit on his life. Luciano was right to act first as Maranzano had planned just that. "Little Caesar" died in September 1931.

Wikimedia Commons

19 of 34

Charles "Lucky" Luciano

Charles Luciano, the Italian-born gangster who operated largely in the U.S., was nicknamed "Lucky" after surviving a vicious beating and having his throat slashed in 1929 when he refused to work for another mob boss.

Others believe it was his gambling, or a simple mispronunciation of his last name, that made the moniker stick. He became the biggest crime boss in America when Salvatore Maranzano died. Luciano himself died of a heart attack in Naples International Airport in 1962.

Wikimedia Commons

20 of 34

James "Whitey" Bulger

James "Whitey" Bulger was both Boston's crime boss and an FBI informant. He garnered his nickname from the cops, who dubbed him "Whitey" for his starkly blonde hair.

Bulger purportedly hated the name, and preferred to be called "Boots" for his penchant for wearing cowboy boots. He was a subject of the CIA's LSD experiments while incarcerated in the 1950s, and beaten to death in prison in 2018.

Donaldson Collection/Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

21 of 34

Enoch "Nucky" Johnson

Enoch Lewis "Nucky" Johnson was the son of Atlantic County, New Jersey's sheriff. He became an important figure in Atlantic City politics, and was criminally involved in bootlegging and gambling.

While his nickname holds no particularly engrossing backstory, his life and crimes — as chronicled in the hit-series Boardwalk Empire — are certainly enthralling. Johnson died in December 1968 at a convalescent home of natural causes.

Bettmann/Getty Images

22 of 34

Arnold "The Brain" Rothstein

Arnold "The Brain" Rothstein was a gambler, racketeer, and the kingpin of the Jewish mob in New York City. This is the man who is widely believed to have fixed the 1919 World Series — and mentored Lucky Luciano, Meyer Lanski, and Frank Costello.

With a business savvy that led him to transform organized crime from primitive disarray to a corporate-like network, the nickname was more than apt. With a fortune estimated to be $50 million, Rothstein was assassinated at the age of 46 in November 1928 after refusing to pay $320,000 he'd lost during a poker game two months prior.

Jack Benton/Getty Images

23 of 34

Albert "The Mad Hatter" or "Lord High Executioner" Anastasia

Albert Anastasia had a slew of nicknames, from "The Mad Hatter" and "The One-Man Army" to "Lord High Executioner." The crime lord and hitman earned them from his ruthless killing as leader of Murder, Inc. — the enforcement arm of the New York mob.

From ice picks to bullets, nothing was off the table for Anastasia. He was assassinated in October 1957, aged 55, gunned down while relaxing in a barber's chair.

Joe Petrella/NY Daily News Archive/Getty Images

24 of 34

Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel

Benjamin "Bugsy" Siegel was one of the first celebrity gangsters. He was not only responsible for helping develop the Las Vegas strip, but was also influential in the Jewish mob and the American Mafia.

Those who knew him said he was always the first to shoot when things got hectic. Given his high temper and tendency toward spontaneous violence, fellow gangsters gave Siegel the moniker, believing he was "crazy as a bed bug."

Wikimedia Commons

25 of 34

Giuseppe "Joe The Boss" Masseria

Giuseppe "Joe The Boss" Masseria fought in the 1930s Castellammarese War to take control over crime in New York City. Unfortunately for him, the war ended with his murder.

As he became head of the Morello family in the late 1920s, the nickname was fairly direct. He replaced Salvatore D'Aquila to become capo dei capi, or "boss of all bosses," in 1928. He was murdered by Lucky Luciano and his men during a meeting in a Coney Island restaurant in April 1931.

Wikimedia Commons

26 of 34

Russell "The Silent Don" Bufalino

Russell "The Silent Don" Bufalino garnered his nickname from making decisions quietly with as little fanfare as possible. As depicted in Martin Scorcese's The Irishman by Joe Pesci, the mobster might've been responsible for Jimmy Hoffa's death.

He was born in Sicily but made his mark in New York City, rising from a petty criminal to a powerful figure in the American Mafia. He was arrested in 1977 for extortion, but remained head of his crime family until he was 90 years old. Bufalino died in a Scranton nursing home in 1994.

Getty Images

27 of 34

Tommy "Three-Finger Brown" Lucchese

Tommy "Three-Finger Brown" Lucchese was a founding member of the Mafia in the U.S. Lucchese ran one of the Five Families that dominated organized crime in New York City.

It was a 1920 arrest for auto theft when one of the booking officers noticed Lucchese's deformed hand — caused by an industrial accident that saw his right thumb and forefinger amputated. The officer compared Lucchese with Mordecai "Three Finger" Brown — a famous baseball pitcher.

He died of a brain tumor in July 1967 at home in Long Island.

Wikimedia Commons

28 of 34

Paul "The Boss Of All Bosses" Castellano

Paul "The Boss Of All Bosses" Castellano was commonly also referred to as "The Howard Hughes of the Mob" for building an empire so vast it motivated aspiring gangsters on the come-up.

Castellano was one of the 61 high-ranking mobsters who attended the infamous Apalachin meeting, before authorities raided it and arrested everyone.

Castellano succeeded Carlo Gambino in 1976 and became a boss, but was murdered in December 1985 at a steakhouse in Manhattan. It's believed John Gotti oversaw the hit, and watched it happen from a car parked across the street.

Getty Images

29 of 34

Frank "The Irishman" Sheeran

Frank "The Irishman" Sheeran purportedly murdered his friend and famous teamster boss, Jimmy Hoffa. The order came from Russell Bufalino himself, after which Hoffa simply disappeared.

The non-Italian was dubbed as such for operating in a predominantly Italian organization, yet was portrayed by Italian-American Robert De Niro in the titular film, The Irishman. Sheeran died in December 2003 at 83 years old.

Sheeran/Brandt/Splash

30 of 34

John "The Teflon Don" Gotti

John Gotti was nicknamed "The Teflon Don" after three high-profile trials in the 1980s failed to convict the mobster of his criminal charges and saw him acquitted. His legal issues became a tabloid spectacle, sparking pro-Gotti demonstrations outside the courthouse and claims of Italian-American discrimination.

Unfortunately, "The Teflon Don" wasn't entirely impervious. In 1992, he was convicted on multiple charges, including the murder of five people, and sentenced to life in prison. Gotti died in June 2002 at the age of 61 from throat cancer.

Keith Meyers/New York Times Co./Getty Images

31 of 34

Salvatore "Sammy The Bull" Gravano

Salvatore "Sammy The Bull" Gravano was 13 when he joined the Rampers street gang in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. When he found out some locals had stolen his bike, he went to confront them and quickly got into a fight.

A few neighborhood gangsters watching this squabble noticed that Gravano never backed down, took on numerous people at once, and fought "like a bull." After a long career in the Colombo family, he became a made man himself, and helped John Gotti kill Paul Castellano before testifying against Gotti in 1993.

Gravano was released from prison in September 2017.

Jeffrey Markowitz/Sygma/Getty Images

32 of 34

Richard "The Iceman" Kuklinski

Richard "The Iceman" Kuklinski was a hitman sentenced to life imprisonment in 1998 for the murder of four men. In 2003, he received another 30-year sentence for confessing to the murder of a police officer. Authorities nicknamed him "The Iceman" after discovering he'd frozen one of his victims in an effort to disguise the time of death.

Kuklinski died in March 2006 of cardiac arrest after 18 years behind bars.

Bettmann/Getty Images

33 of 34

Giovanni "The Pig" or "The People Slayer" Brusca

Giovanni Brusca murdered anti-Mafia prosecutor Giovanni Falcone, whom Tomasso "The Boss of Two Worlds" Buscetta worked with to expose members of organized crime and corrupt politicians. The pudgy, hairy murderer was dubbed "The Pig" for his unkempt appearance by fellow mobsters.

Brusca once claimed he had killed between 100 and 200 people. Buscetta said Brusca was "a wild stallion but a great leader." He has been imprisoned since 1996 for multiple murders.

Wikimedia Commons

34 of 34

Like this gallery?
Share it:

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Delena Feil

Last Updated: 02/20/2023

Views: 6527

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (45 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Delena Feil

Birthday: 1998-08-29

Address: 747 Lubowitz Run, Sidmouth, HI 90646-5543

Phone: +99513241752844

Job: Design Supervisor

Hobby: Digital arts, Lacemaking, Air sports, Running, Scouting, Shooting, Puzzles

Introduction: My name is Delena Feil, I am a clean, splendid, calm, fancy, jolly, bright, faithful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.